![Main Logo](/assets/frc-blue-logo.svg)
Filter Your Search
4-Bedroom Houses for Rent in Fire Island, NY
94 Houses Available
- Default
- Lowest Price
- Highest Price
- Newest Listings
Filter Your Search
![Building Photo - 201 Cottage Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/L3Y_g1oXLLr2S3s38UR2fhjCQ0wUmmAMQAQLuWQITsE/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
5 Beds $6,450
![Building Photo - 931 Dune Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/r9zDCBCS6qg00BEhGu6H9WMOOUvngR7OlvLks8K57hw/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $80,000
![Building Photo - 908 Evergreen Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/D2l0msHWa_u7ja0OX7g7ahONVp9WTbg0eJwXodlazpo/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $8,400
![Building Photo - 803 Dune Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/soLRPnGkjiAFLbx6VbiV3K3UJwxDfy6eg6Pm155hprQ/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $45,000
![Building Photo - 45 Evergreen Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/zv21RRA78L1_h4m7p76m4gf9A1aXJHGL5--tXUO--cQ/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $8,000
![Building Photo - 39 Seneca Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/OADop-e7vmmkt3LNpN3mV9jfzlCIc_efDY8ncrDAN2U/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
5 Beds $12,000
![Building Photo - 804 Evergreen Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/NQkpZ-iWXPwprYTEx9uBH8SXkNBC-h6oKrkCtjOCbmI/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $5,500
![Building Photo - 835 Dune Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/Ur8FwSVv7by2jMblYXRjr8brWmnsPOlZJV5T-uBfy2A/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
6 Beds $80,000
![Building Photo - 291 Cottage Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/vqJRmbjx4_M9kwMz-4avT1r15kbqo-K08kbfiZIgCWY/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $6,000
![Building Photo - 240 Wilmot Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/n-ZAfY087Q7mRZiqUzhyXqB5kG7cvgCRyjdiN6-vp1c/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
5 Beds $17,500
![Building Photo - 101 Bungalow Ln Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/eV7172yx5oP8ziTMYGqW65Y3_CgB8Bw00hxup54HtXc/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $8,250
![Building Photo - 88 Bungalow Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/_K_z4jnu_VuBtSRiM8JEIAbZeKSS_8Jn9-n-aWM0BXY/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $12,000
![Building Photo - 149 Bungalow Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/sCJ0eeKGqXzLhifB7zi_3lEF7qDc4v2U8oyVn6-PrLA/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
5 Beds $11,000
![Building Photo - 32 Schooner Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/0FWPrcOlmHRrqN9Z8R73d7H9FliPqrV2CV5XgkjDhwk/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $10,000
![Building Photo - 31 Homesite](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/ZCZAGeAeRM8Ieum1Z2fN8iDXuUmruINhnBYS6jJ0aQg/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $7,500
![Building Photo - 177 Wilmot Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/UoK4BvZ6F1qD-ptKViipOiqipIj22p_nwu9Mqis9PZY/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $7,500
![Building Photo - 338 Surf Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/yaqIl2-uEznpXZKqZwbMofvfrifqSmNmt746Wo89LVc/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
5 Beds $13,000
![Building Photo - 335 Surf Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/Hs-lnFwU5IKszXXGBIo0eANxg0f8yG0USxICyKzGBKs/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
5 Beds $14,000
![Building Photo - 736 Ocean Breeze Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/BQtb8HgwHuea-UVAfJ2KbK6S5RWC6os8-phq7U3wktw/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $8,000
![Building Photo - 674 Ocean Breeze Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/Yko52XL-G2QnF91fDHvIGwhAVc8nrVDsXEfo0vsp8b4/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
5 Beds $12,000
![Building Photo - 340 Surf Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/7ZjbBHRl24tpr-89RCwDQdig9s1xm7sKs1iNOYHKV-c/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
5 Beds $13,000
![Building Photo - 35 Beachwold Ave Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/C3QtrktvBzUqXwzCWgt7duWmzOm2pe3yDuEOndmeiPs/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
5 Beds $6,000
![Building Photo - 36 Beachwold Ave Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/USBina4i1gcbS5wPVAX_6VYArYPGAjTr_4k4AR7eyXM/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $13,000
![Building Photo - 18 Beachwold Ave Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/dznESHcIjeOXYBMYGzr0HF0t0B2_8wlRImcdPzaPDb4/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $5,500
![Building Photo - 866 Evergreen Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/-6A6EQNHGXDDwr6cSdVdEjYzRcccHHCZqVbr8KY-qyE/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $6,000
![Building Photo - 345 Dehnhoff Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/F1l6PheSNp5u4O8qCqhS8DHmkEsbucVzwFc8FHAb5ck/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
5 Beds $13,000
![Building Photo - 342 Dehnhoff Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/qivWb6O3vCXxQeYPAKtrn2dSaP2Xvi5inpD2epl1O00/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $7,150
![Building Photo - 27 Crescent Ave Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/4u-g16uMn13adD826WSKjloOq_W3y5H3T5vC4T8LgFU/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $7,150
![Building Photo - 311 Wilmot Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/LiZILFS9SirRvVc_a-_OdremEYAnKswHjwHbb1bny48/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $10,500
![Building Photo - 49 Surf Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/z-lePVo9mEUjBprQ6xrdFC3ZkVyeWdMMUq5BA19LSy8/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $7,000
![Building Photo - 45 Beachwold Ave Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/OGXaGPvmbe-5sxaK2TRw0Kh6voaXQiAGLpI0kHyRW2c/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $6,700
![Building Photo - 362 Surf Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/RPMnHMpUjcWmsBy1s5A9cUEwL2RSjiZwEtl6Elvaxy8/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $9,750
![Building Photo - 187 Cottage Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/y9reSTflROuS2NqOqRjYJWIw9yguGlFyZI_JySJsWm0/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $7,500
![Building Photo - 860 Ocean View Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/gU2PHuz1Ob9ydI_iCz84Gyw6j50M8Ly6MXk674Maf48/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
7 Beds $13,000
![Building Photo - 386 Dehnhoff Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/xgJ9qPECKDUK023bXkWMNa9bY5bie8khllKTizujngw/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
5 Beds $13,000
![Building Photo - 731 Ocean Breeze Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/jnh3Z6vQZ3OQkZ9w73s9SKh92C1VN-kPHH_URW6QVvc/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $6,000
![Building Photo - 603 Bayberry Walk Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/4D-cOKc8fDhz4EFoDKxDi2bnenZAKmRirMPNrKiIpLI/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $9,500
![Building Photo - 352 Surf Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/BoBT_BJ6cgy2iRZteH_hQ8dgjn441oSILPj3tx5bZOI/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $12,000
![Building Photo - 20 Ocean Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/NN9eUwOA5hSlyep01NaY5ble5mQE6umbs_R0cKcF6rQ/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $5,000
![Building Photo - 109 Bungalow Ln Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/LdOC_qIBJLAAgvdA_49LS5CajOD6YF93LviwwGSOwpw/117/image.jpg?p=1)
House for Rent
4 Beds $13,000