![Main Logo](/assets/frc-blue-logo.svg)
Filter Your Search
Apartments for Rent in Setauket, NY
234 Apartments Available
- Default
- Lowest Price
- Highest Price
- Newest Listings
Filter Your Search
![Building Photo - 119 E Main St Unit 1B Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/uceRTonR299VIHUrMQ9SaEkRU4vAoa4LJfxLeqecZK0/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
1 Bed $2,400
![Building Photo - 64 Pinnacle Dr Unit 64 Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/EAz_nmilkQJ8RZSJIxKi71oA3PwewQvlaHKPL3IVosw/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
1 Bed $2,995
![Building Photo - 119 E Main St Unit 2A Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/hlVtyjeUNUXGuqSsl5HnF0sOll5AmdXnLaJg4UETA_0/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
1 Bed $2,200
![Building Photo - 268 Hallock Rd Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/Xxpup5BAUtY2Fj2-dbS5TRrTv9_FtX8oKFMlhPKOyTw/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
1 Bed $1,100
![Building Photo - 2 Presidents Dr Unit 2-3B Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/ZmimwCw-CmMFAqD8R5OeYv-F7IYU3ZO2PaKdFFQGkEs/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
2 Beds $2,895
![Building Photo - 24 Pinnacle Dr Unit 24 Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/-w0xYRoVrr7VdpY9UdPAnCAqQTNw0WdtLzoiBLxYYow/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
1 Bed $2,995
![Building Photo - 140 A E Main St Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/HaQR8Lw4e-dBaFmk4dXmvCjSER6AuQfhoVx6aw5kMNc/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
1 Bed $2,800
![Building Photo - 113 Village Green Dr Unit 113 Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/MliOdCTNvMKF5HIZRXA-jKKXe-ivB0EaTHRKHaD31O8/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
2 Beds $3,160
![Building Photo - 29 Neal Path Unit 29 Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/yZttCHZVxRXXz9oU2dC90lzbxvEpUiJ2jwD-zllrH9M/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
2 Beds $4,120
![Building Photo - 21 Balin Ave Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/aDQYu-N4QFEnww7O59fSz69OtvsN_tXAAXwRo9ib6D4/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
1 Bed $1,800
![Building Photo - 49 Neal Path Unit 49 Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/gIGQnCDcnOJf7vUTu4bhEW5grFNXvcz51b9ZnJvjdPU/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
3 Beds $4,215
![Building Photo - 116 E Main St Unit 2 Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/oqZIbFs2ti3XQCZz9l8Sfvl7AmjQgZDamB6pH9IAadU/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
Studio $2,350
![Building Photo - 156 W Broadway Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/BLFsAIkKswfckx8dUIDB8i7bZe8bdChZ8ukY6494k3g/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
1 Bed $2,700
![Building Photo - 7 Neal Path Unit 7 Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/ZL243lUA0b5y464hCcMpnFlQCII6k8PzK4TxQaqQEj8/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
2 Beds $4,145
![Building Photo - 1 Presidents Dr Unit 5-1A Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/AFngSa1SudTjZf6tBruTyytG5ZUMQIrURWWGEhoHfH0/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
1 Bed $2,435
![Building Photo - 2 Presidents Dr Unit 2-3A Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/zL2cHFSEZS2ZXnfkO8-KnGytkw4Jz0_u73pFZpz0kYc/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
2 Beds $2,650
![Building Photo - 138 E Broadway Unit B Rental](https://images1.forrent.com/i2/gr8Clcl-QpfxoLINqrTVtxb09TyiNF6Fc_cLodX-xl8/117/image.jpg?p=1)
Apartment for Rent
1 Bed $2,800