
Filter Your Search
All Filters
Rent Range
-Houses for Rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY
56 Houses Available
Sort
- Default
- Lowest Price
- Highest Price
- Newest Listings
Filter Your Search
Find Your Next House for Rent
Discover 56 rental homes in Shelter Island Heights, NY. A single-family residence is a house in the most traditional sense: a standalone structure with four walls and a roof, intended for a family unit.Living in a rental house is a step between renting and homeownership. While you won’t have the financial responsibility of a down payment and mortgage, you’ll have the opportunity to take care of a bigger space and practice small maintenance responsibilities, such as mowing the lawn and other landscaping. Larger maintenance tasks and utility replacements are typically covered by the property manager, like in any other rental type. Rental homes also allow you to enjoy private amenities, such as attached garages and pools only available to you and your direct community. Embracing your home without the permanence of homeownership allows you to enjoy this next step at your own pace.
Frequently Asked Questions
Average Rent Rates
What's the average rent for a house in Shelter Island Heights, NY?
House averages in Shelter Island Heights, NY varies based on size.
- $36,750 for a 3-bedroom house in Shelter Island Heights, NY
- $38,250 for a 4-bedroom house in Shelter Island Heights, NY
Find More Houses for Rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY
Shelter Island Heights Houses for Rent by Amenity
Find Rentals Near Shelter Island Heights, NY
Shelter Island Heights Neighborhoods with Houses
- Houses for Rent in Shorewood Farm
- Houses for Rent in Silver Beach
- Houses for Rent in Ram Head Club Estates
- Houses for Rent in Menantic Colony Shelter Island
- Houses for Rent in Longview at Shelter Island
- Houses for Rent in Eastward
- Houses for Rent in Eastern Suffolk
- Houses for Rent in Shelterlands
- Houses for Rent in North Haven Shores
- Houses for Rent in Cleaves Point
- Houses for Rent in Fordham Acres