Rentals in Shelter Island, NY

Looking for apartments for rent in Shelter Island, NY? Find the right fit with 23 available rentals on ForRent.com. From modern downtown high-rises to spacious suburban rentals, ForRent makes it easy to find Shelter Island apartments that fit your lifestyle and budget.

No matter what's on your list of apartment must-haves, ForRent has you covered. Find an apartment in Shelter Island with short-term lease options, fitness centers, and utilities included. Use our filters to find Shelter Island apartments with features like in-unit laundry, balconies, garages, and pet-friendly spaces. Explore different rental types, from one to four-bedroom apartments in Shelter Island to single-family homes, townhomes, and condos. Browse listings now and secure your next apartment in Shelter Island, NY.