Filter Your Search

Rentals in Shelter Island, NY

23 Rentals Available

Find Your Next Rental

Looking for apartments for rent in Shelter Island, NY? Find the right fit with 23 available rentals on ForRent.com. From modern downtown high-rises to spacious suburban rentals, ForRent makes it easy to find Shelter Island apartments that fit your lifestyle and budget.

No matter what's on your list of apartment must-haves, ForRent has you covered. Find an apartment in Shelter Island with short-term lease options, fitness centers, and utilities included. Use our filters to find Shelter Island apartments with features like in-unit laundry, balconies, garages, and pet-friendly spaces. Explore different rental types, from one to four-bedroom apartments in Shelter Island to single-family homes, townhomes, and condos. Browse listings now and secure your next apartment in Shelter Island, NY.

Frequently Asked Questions

Rental Requirements

Can I find a short-term apartment in Shelter Island, NY?

There are 1 short-term apartment in Shelter Island, NY.

Find More Rentals in Shelter Island, NY

Find Rentals Near Shelter Island, NY