Filter Your Search
All Filters
Rent Range
-Houses for Rent in Bay Shore, NY
8 Houses Available
Sort
- Default
- Lowest Price
- Highest Price
- Newest Listings
Filter Your Search
Find Your Next House for Rent
Discover a variety of houses for rent in Bay Shore, NY on ForRent.com. Whether you're moving to the area or just looking for a change of scenery, our listings offer a wide selection of homes that cater to different needs and budgets. From charming single-family homes to larger, more spacious residences, each listing comes with detailed descriptions and photos to help you make an informed decision. Start your search today to find your perfect home in Bay Shore.
Frequently Asked Questions
Average Rent Rates
What's the average rent in Bay Shore, NY?
Rent averages in Bay Shore, NY vary based on size.
- $2,547 for a 1-bedroom rental in Bay Shore, NY
- $3,071 for a 2-bedroom rental in Bay Shore, NY
- $4,016 for a 3-bedroom rental in Bay Shore, NY
Education
What elementary schools are in Bay Shore, NY?
There are several great elementary schools in Bay Shore, NY. ForRent.com can help you find a house near Southwest Elementary School, Gardiner Manor School, Hemlock Elementary School, and others.
What middle schools are in Bay Shore, NY?
ForRent.com can help you find a new house in Bay Shore, NY, near middle schools like Bay Shore Middle School, West Middle School, and others.
What high schools are in Bay Shore, NY?
Search ForRent.com to find a new house in Bay Shore, NY, located near high schools like Bay Shore Senior High School, and others.
Find More Houses for Rent in Bay Shore, NY
Bedrooms
Bay Shore Houses for Rent by Amenity
Houses in your Budget
Find Rentals Near Bay Shore, NY
Homes for Rent near Bay Shore
- House Rentals in Brightwaters
- House Rentals in West Bay Shore
- House Rentals in Islip
- House Rentals in North Bay Shore
- House Rentals in West Islip
- House Rentals in Edgewood
- House Rentals in Brentwood
- House Rentals in North Babylon
- Townhouses For Rent in Islip
- Townhouses For Rent in West Islip
- Townhouses For Rent in Edgewood
- Townhouses For Rent in Brentwood
- Townhouses For Rent in North Babylon
Bay Shore Neighborhoods with Houses
- Houses for Rent in West Bay Shore
- Houses for Rent in Western Fire Island
- Houses for Rent in Southwestern Suffolk
- Houses for Rent in Western Suffolk
- Houses for Rent in Central Suffolk
- Houses for Rent in Southeastern Nassau
- Houses for Rent in Eastern Nassau
- Houses for Rent in Northern Nassau
- Houses for Rent in Central Nassau
- Houses for Rent in Downtown Bay Shore
Houses for Rent near Colleges in Bay Shore
- Houses for Rent near SUNY Suffolk County Community College-Michael J. Grant Campus
- Houses for Rent near Farmingdale State College
- Houses for Rent near SUNY Suffolk County Community College-Ammerman Campus
- Houses for Rent near Stony Brook University
- Houses for Rent near The College at Old Westbury, State University of New York
- Houses for Rent near SUNY Nassau Community College-West and East Campus