Filter Your Search
All Filters
Rent Range
-Rentals in Bay Shore, NY
210 Rentals Available
Sort
- Default
- Lowest Price
- Highest Price
- Newest Listings
Filter Your Search
1 Month Free
Specials
Discounts
Discounts
Specials
Specials
Discounts
1 Month Free
Specials
Specials
Find your next Rental
Discover the perfect rental in Bay Shore, NY with ForRent.com. Browse apartments, single-family houses, townhomes, and condos, all in one convenient location. By searching all rentals, you have the flexibility to compare homes that are for rent by owner or available through property management companies. Use our advanced filters to narrow your search by price, amenities, and more. ForRent.com makes it easy to find a place in Bay Shore, New York that perfectly fits your lifestyle and budget.
Frequently Asked Questions
Average Rent Rates
What's the average rent in Bay Shore, NY?
Rent averages in Bay Shore, NY vary based on size.
- $2,466 for a 1-bedroom rental in Bay Shore, NY
- $3,067 for a 2-bedroom rental in Bay Shore, NY
- $4,028 for a 3-bedroom rental in Bay Shore, NY
Rental Requirements
Can I find a short-term apartment in Bay Shore, NY?
There are 14 short-term apartments in Bay Shore, NY.
Transportation
How do people usually get around Bay Shore, NY?
Residents in Bay Shore, NY usually get around by car. According to Walk Score, Bay Shore, NY falls within the Car Dependent range.
Education
What colleges and universities are in Bay Shore, NY?
If you’re a college or university student moving to Bay Shore, NY, ForRent.com can help you find a rental near Touro University-Law Center, SUNY Suffolk Co. Grant Campus-Michael J. Grant Campus, Farmingdale State College and others.
Find More Rentals in Bay Shore, NY
Other Types of Rentals
Bay Shore Rentals by Amenity
Bay Shore Specialty Rentals
Rentals in your Budget
Find Rentals Near Bay Shore, NY
Bay Shore Neighborhoods with Rentals
- For Rent in Downtown Bay Shore
- For Rent in Awixa Creek Estates
- For Rent in Windsor Park
- For Rent in Western Fire Island
- For Rent in Olympic Park
- For Rent in North Bay Shore
- For Rent in West Bay Shore
- For Rent in Southwestern Suffolk
- For Rent in Western Suffolk
- For Rent in Central Suffolk
- For Rent in Southeastern Nassau
- For Rent in Eastern Nassau
- For Rent in Northern Nassau
- For Rent in Central Nassau
Rentals near Colleges in Bay Shore
- Rentals near SUNY Suffolk County Community College-Michael J. Grant Campus
- Rentals near Farmingdale State College
- Rentals near SUNY Suffolk County Community College-Ammerman Campus
- Rentals near Stony Brook University
- Rentals near The College at Old Westbury, State University of New York
- Rentals near SUNY Nassau Community College-West and East Campus