Filter Your Search

Apartments for Rent in Downtown Bay Shore

208 Apartments Available

  1. Building Photo - Shoregate Rental
    1 Month Free

    Shoregate

    143 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    Studio - 3 Beds$2,530 - $4,455

Find your next Apartment

You found 208 available rentals in Downtown Bay Shore, Bay Shore. Refine your search by using the filter at the top of the page to view 1, 2 or 3+ bedroom units, as well as cheap, pet friendly rentals with utilities included and more. Use our customizable guide to narrow down options.

Living in Downtown Bay Shore, NY

Downtown Bay Shore is a coastal town 40 miles east of New York City along the southern shoreline of Long Island. Enjoy some fresh air and ocean views with a ferry ride from Fire Island Ferries. Renters avoiding traffic into New York City can easily take a water taxi to and from the city. Various boat shows and fishing tournaments take place in the Bay Shore Marina along the southern region of the neighborhood. Take a walk along the shore at Benjamin Memorial Beach or shoot hoops at Shipwreck Cove Spray Park. There are plenty of outdoor adventures awaiting in Downtown Bay Shore. Renters will relish in the vibrant atmosphere this coastal city offers. There are plentiful eateries, spas, and restaurants offering wine tastings and popular happy hours. To learn more about the history of the neighborhood, visit the Bay Shore Historical Society.

Find More Apartments for Rent in Downtown Bay Shore

Find Rentals Near Downtown Bay Shore