Filter Your Search

Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

210 Apartments Available

  1. Building Photo - Shoregate Rental
    1 Month Free

    Shoregate

    143 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    Studio - 3 Beds $2,515 - $9,966

Find your next Apartment for Rent

Looking for apartments for rent in Bay Shore, NY? Find the right fit with 210 available rentals on ForRent.com. From modern downtown high-rises to spacious suburban rentals, ForRent makes it easy to find Bay Shore apartments that fit your lifestyle and budget.

No matter what's on your list of apartment must-haves, ForRent has you covered. Find an apartment in Bay Shore with short-term lease options, fitness centers, and utilities included. Use our filters to find Bay Shore apartments with features like in-unit laundry, balconies, garages, and pet-friendly spaces. Explore different rental types, from one to four-bedroom apartments in Bay Shore to single-family homes, townhomes, and condos. Browse listings now and secure your next apartment in Bay Shore, NY.

Living in Bay Shore NY

The Long Island hamlet of Bay Shore sits on the Great South Bay and the Great Cove waters on the island's South Shore. Benjamin's Memorial Beach is a particular hotspot for the area and is well-travelled by both residents and visitors from the Big Apple. Bay Shore's Main Street area is lined with seafood restaurants, coffee shops, local ice cream parlors, and bars and breweries near the water. Locals head to Westfield South Shore, a large shopping center just north of the Sunrise Highway, to enjoy upscale shopping and more dining options. The Southern State Parkway is the area's largest thoroughfare, but Bay Shore is easily accessible by public transit. Rentals in Bay Shore include recently renovated waterfront properties and both upscale and more affordable apartments scattered around the area.

Frequently Asked Questions

Average Rent Rates

What's the average rent in Bay Shore, NY?

Rent averages in Bay Shore, NY vary based on size.

Find More Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

Find Rentals Near Bay Shore, NY