
Filter Your Search
All Filters
Rent Range
-4-Bedroom Houses for Rent in Shelter Island, NY
29 Houses Available
Sort
- Default
- Lowest Price
- Highest Price
- Newest Listings
Filter Your Search
Find Your Next 4-Bedroom House for Rent
Find 29 four-bedroom houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY. A four-bedroom house is a unit with four distinct bedrooms that share a common area and kitchen. Depending on the floor plan, each room may share or have its own bathroom. If roommates split the cost of a four-bedroom rental, it can be a very affordable option. Additionally, units with more bedrooms typically offer a larger living space, allowing renters to make room for shared furniture or host guests.
Find More Houses for Rent in Shelter Island, NY
Other Types of Rentals
Shelter Island Houses for Rent by Amenity
Find Rentals Near Shelter Island, NY
Shelter Island Neighborhoods with Houses
- Houses for Rent in Shorewood Farm
- Houses for Rent in Silver Beach
- Houses for Rent in Ram Head Club Estates
- Houses for Rent in North Haven Shores
- Houses for Rent in Longview at Shelter Island
- Houses for Rent in Shelterlands
- Houses for Rent in Eastward
- Houses for Rent in Menantic Colony Shelter Island
- Houses for Rent in Eastern Suffolk